Tzedakah and Money

Giving Maaser to a Charity That Benefits You

Can I give my maaser (10%) to a charity that also benefits me?

Last updated

Short answer

Maaser goes to tzedakah. It is not for paying your own obligations or buying yourself benefits. When you get something back, like a dinner or a raffle ticket, only the amount above the value of what you received can count as maaser.

How the traditions see it

  • Ashkenazi / Litvish: Most follow the guidance of the Chofetz Chaim in Ahavat Chesed and Rav Moshe Feinstein's responsa: maaser should not pay for things you are already obligated in.
  • Sephardi / Mizrachi: Similar in principle. Rav Ovadia Yosef's rulings also stress that relatives in need come first.
  • Modern Orthodox: Many follow the same principles and often discuss with their rav how day school tuition fits in, since it is such a large part of the family budget.

The core principle

Giving a tenth of your income to tzedakah is a widely kept practice, and many poskim treat it as very strong. Since it is set aside for the poor and for Torah, it should not be used to pay your own debts or to buy things for yourself.

Common cases

Dinner tickets and raffles: only the amount above the value of what you received. If a dinner costs $250 and the meal is worth $50, about $200 can come from maaser.

Shul dues and your children's tuition: debated. Many poskim say no for basic obligations, because you would have to pay them anyway. Some allow part of tuition in specific cases, for example amounts above the basic cost, or when a family would otherwise not manage. This is a classic question for your rav.

Needy relatives: allowed, and even preferred. The Shulchan Aruch says your own poor relatives come before others. That can include an adult child or a parent who is struggling.

A charity you run: allowed, as long as you take no personal benefit from the money, such as a salary or perks paid from your own maaser.

Mitzvah items you are obligated in, like your own tefillin or a lulav: the Rema writes that maaser money should not be used for them.

The tnai, a condition

Many people make a condition when they start giving maaser, saying that they may use it for certain mitzvah expenses. Poskim discuss this as a way to give flexibility from the start. If you did not make one, you can speak to your rav about doing so now.

Sources

Ask your rav if...

  • You are unsure whether tuition, dues or a family need can count.
  • You want to set up a tnai, a condition, for how you use your maaser.
  • Your income is complex, such as a business, gifts or investments, and you are not sure what to count.

Shaylah is a learning tool, not a posek. For a practical ruling, ask your rabbi.

Your situation is a little different?

Ask a Follow Up

More common questions

All common questions