Converting to Judaism Before Marriage
Can a woman convert before we get married, and is that okay?
Last updated
Short answer
She can convert, but an Orthodox conversion must be sincere and for its own sake, with a real acceptance of the mitzvot. Converting in order to marry is a classic concern. Many batei din will still accept a candidate who started because of a relationship, if over time the commitment becomes genuine.
How the traditions see it
- All Orthodox communities: The requirements are the same everywhere: sincere acceptance of mitzvot, tevila in a mikvah, brit mila for men, and a proper Orthodox beit din.
- Where courts differ: Batei din differ in how long the study period is, how they judge a candidate whose interest began with a relationship, and what level of community involvement they expect. Some are known for being more cautious, some more welcoming. All of them need to see a real, lasting commitment.
Why marriage is a concern
The Talmud (Yevamot 24b) says that someone who converts for the sake of marriage is not accepted at first, because the conversion may not be for its own sake. The Rambam and the Shulchan Aruch bring this down as law.
At the same time, the poskim recognize that people's reasons grow. Many great authorities wrote that if a candidate started because of a relationship and has since come to love Torah and keep the mitzvot, the beit din can accept her. The question is not how it started but where it is now.
What the process looks like
Study, often one to two years, with a teacher the beit din approves. Living an observant life: Shabbat, kashrut, prayer, family purity, and being part of an Orthodox community.
A recognized Orthodox beit din. In the US, for example, the RCA's GPS network of conversion courts is widely accepted. In Israel, the Chief Rabbinate's conversion courts. Ask early which court will be accepted where you plan to live and marry.
At the end: tevila in a mikvah for everyone, and brit mila for men.
The couple usually should not be living together during the process. Many batei din will ask about this directly.
Things to know up front
A non Orthodox conversion is not recognized for an Orthodox marriage.
There is no shortcut. A conversion that is rushed or arranged can later be questioned, which can hurt the convert and the children most of all. Patience protects everyone.
Sources
Ask your rav if...
- Speak to a beit din early, ideally before wedding plans are set.
- One of you was raised in a non Orthodox community and you are unsure of your own Jewish status.
- There was a past conversion and you want to know whether it will be accepted.
Shaylah is a learning tool, not a posek. For a practical ruling, ask your rabbi.
Your situation is a little different?
Ask a Follow UpMore common questions
- Eating Non Kosher Food in an Emergency
- Giving Maaser to a Charity That Benefits You
- How Long to Wait Between Meat and Dairy
- What Bracha on Granola and Cereal